Book Growth Analysis Call +1 (800) 230-5165 Book a Call

Technician Productivity: Who’s Responsible for Tech Pay?

Service Drive Revolution — Episode #384

Official Full Transcript

Host: Chris Collins

Guests: Adam Krey and Chris Hogland

Published: November 16, 2026

Duration: 56:07

Listen on Apple | Listen on Spotify

Who is responsible when a technician isn’t making money? Service managers often point at the tech. Techs point at the advisor, the dispatch board, or the work that never showed up. Everybody has a theory about technician productivity, and very few stores have a plan.

That question was the heart of Episode #384 of Service Drive Revolution, where Chris Collins and the team sat down with Manny the Mechanic. Manny is a 26-year flat-rate technician who has built a following on Instagram and TikTok by talking straight about work ethic, pay, and what it takes to produce in the shop. He defends flat rate, and he also calls out both techs and management when they get it wrong. Here’s what service advisors and service managers can take from the conversation.


Why Your Best Technicians Are Walking Out the Door

Manny has interviewed plenty of technicians who left dealerships, and he sees a pattern. The people leaving tend to be either the best techs or the weakest. Top performers ask why they should stay when they could open their own shops. Low producers tend to drift out as well. Meanwhile, the middle group Manny calls “the cruisers” stays put, turning seven or eight hours a day.

Here’s the part that should sting for management. In 26 years, Manny says, nobody in leadership sat down and asked how things could be better until his auto group started a technician meeting a few months ago. It was the first sign the group understood that techs are leaving, and that nothing else works without them. Chris made the same point from the coaching side: when you ask your people how to go to war every day, you’re often blown away by how smart they are.

SERVICE MANAGERS: schedule a technician roundtable this month. Ask what slows them down, then act on what you hear.


Your Advisor Is the Technician’s Customer

Manny offers a mindset shift that many techs miss. The owner of the car is not the technician’s customer; the service advisor is. When a tech documents the inspection clearly, shoots a video, and briefs the advisor, the advisor can sell the work with confidence.

Some techs resist this because they feel they’re doing the advisor’s job for them. Manny sees it differently. Informing your advisor is how you set up the sale, and a well-informed advisor sells more of the work you’ve already found.

Advisors, the responsibility runs both ways. Manny coached a brand-new advisor with one rule: be direct. Customers, including lawyers and doctors, read body language and pick up on uncertainty fast. If you don’t know whether a repair will fix the problem, say so, then explain what the tech found and what the plan is. And if the car’s value doesn’t justify the repair, such as a 2012 vehicle with a dead cylinder, it may be time to talk about a trade-in. Older vehicles tend to bring “cousins,” where one failure invites the next, so value belongs in the conversation.


Technician Productivity Starts With Capacity

Chris shared results from stores his team has coached, and the common thread is techs:

  • One Midwest Ford store swung from negative 65% net-to-gross to positive 43.65% over six months, adding about six technicians along the way.
  • A Hyundai store went from 20% to 35% net-to-gross in a single month and quickly hired two techs.
  • Hours per RO climbed from 1.35 to 1.59 at a Subaru store, where ELR rose from $156 to $166 and net-to-gross moved from negative 30% to positive 2% in the first month.
  • Net profit more than doubled, up 224%, across an 11-location heavy truck group, and all 11 departments were profitable for the first time.
  • A Kia store moved from 20% to 41% net-to-gross.

The lesson is hard to miss. You can’t turn a department around without adding capacity. Chris says that training only the advisors leads to an implosion every time, because advisors who sell more work can’t get it done without enough techs, and then the techs revolt. Advisors also hold back on selling because they fear hurting CSI, even as they’re told to sell more.

Fixed absorption is back in the spotlight as a metric, too. When fixed ops can send $150,000 a month to the bottom line, it can effectively save a dealership that’s losing money up front. If you want to understand how absorption differs from gross profit, read our breakdown of service absorption vs. gross profit.

how to fix shop culture

Flat Rate Rewards the Techs Who Take Ownership

Manny’s dad gave him blunt advice when he complained about work: if you clock in on someone else’s dime, take responsibility, or open your own shop. Manny took it to heart. Flat rate, in his view, lets technicians control their own destiny. As long as the work is there, you can earn as much as you’re willing to produce.

His own target is 20 hours in a day, and he’s open that some days he hits more and some days less. He also warns younger techs to be careful what they wish for when they say they want to flag what he flags. That pace means a 20-minute lunch and constant motion.

His habits are practical, and they’re worth sharing with your team:

  • Block out the whole world except your stall and the car in front of you.
  • Keep your stall clean and know where your tools are. Manny works from one cart and never opens his toolbox.
  • Remember that every extra step costs you money.
  • Study at home, from wiring diagrams to timing belt procedures. Homework never ends in this trade.

Skills take five to ten years to hone, Manny says, and cars keep changing, so the learning never stops. If a young tech isn’t willing to study every day, he says, this probably isn’t the industry for them.

Chris offered a counterpoint from heavy-truck dealerships, where most techs are hourly. When his team adds bonus programs there, some techs don’t realize they can flag more than 100%. Chris sees that as a leadership failure, because if techs don’t understand how to earn more, that’s on management to teach them. For SERVICE MANAGERS, it’s a reminder to explain your pay plan clearly, whether it’s flat rate or hourly with a bonus.


Own the Comeback: Two Days or 30 Miles

Few things frustrate customers more than a check-engine light that returns right after a repair. Chris asked Manny a simple question: if the light comes back within two days or 30 miles, whose problem is it? Manny’s answer was that it’s on the shop. The customer doesn’t know why the light is back, only that they paid to fix it, and Manny won’t charge a second diagnosis to sort it out.

Here’s how his quality check keeps the tech productive by handing the driving to a porter:

  1. The tech takes a test drive of four or five miles and confirms the vehicle gets through readiness.
  2. A porter drives roughly 20 miles, shuts the car off, locks it, and lets it go to sleep.
  3. After a second key cycle, the porter drives another 20 miles back.

Forty miles with two key cycles gives you solid confidence, even though modern drive cycles are hard to hit, without burning a tech’s flat-rate time.

Set expectations before the repair, too. When a car arrives with several codes, tell the customer which repair you expect to fix the problem and that the other codes could return. Manny compares it to hoses: they were born together, grew up together, and find the path of least resistance, so replacing one often exposes the next. Customers who hear that upfront don’t feel blindsided later.

A thorough inspection protects the store as well. Manny has watched techs recommend $8,000 worth of catalytic converters without ever checking the cooling system, the brakes, or the oil. At a dealership labor rate, customers expect more than a single-code answer.

Manny also leans on AI for this. He gives ChatGPT the codes, asks for a plain-language explanation of each, and has it draft a template that tells the advisor what the first repair addresses and what might come back. Our post on how dealerships should train service advisors to use AI covers how to roll that out safely.


Profit Doesn’t Come From Cutting Expenses

A listener asked which three expenses run too high when Chris inspects dealer financials. The answers were light-hearted: uniforms for employees who were fired six months ago, and brake-clean cans bought one at a time instead of in bulk. Be a good steward of your department, Chris says, and check your uniform bill.

The bigger point is that across hundreds of stores, his team has never scaled profit by cutting expenses. Two levers matter far more. Discounting is usually out of control, and shop efficiency drives gross-profit percentage. Picture two quick-lube techs per stall at $25 an hour each. That’s $50 an hour in labor on a single stall, and the math rarely works. Focus on inefficiency and unproductive wages instead, and if you want to know what shapes technician pay in the first place, see our post on what factors affect mechanic labor costs.


Growing the Next Generation of Technicians

Manny worries about the pipeline. High schools cut wood shop, metal shop, and auto shop, and Southern California’s racing culture faded along with them. Dealerships, meanwhile, are major employers. Manny points to his hometown of Whittier, which lost four dealerships along with the jobs and sales tax revenue that came with them. A technician career offers solid pay without the student loan debt many college graduates carry, and Manny, who never went to college, calls it a special way to make a living.


Key Takeaways for SERVICE ADVISORS and SERVICE MANAGERS

  • Ask your technicians what’s getting in their way, then act on it.
  • Treat the advisor-tech relationship as customer and supplier.
  • Build shop capacity before you ramp up selling.
  • Teach your pay plan plainly so techs understand how to earn more.
  • Track comebacks and define a quality check that doesn’t burn flat-rate time.
  • Focus on efficiency and discounting rather than cutting expenses.

Want to hear the full conversation? Listen to Episode #384 of Service Drive Revolution. If your advisors need help turning inspections into approved work, explore service advisor training from Chris Collins Inc.


Frequently Asked Questions About Technician Productivity

Who is responsible for a technician making money?

The responsibility is shared. Technicians control their own stall, from how organized they are to how many steps they waste. Management owns shop capacity, a clearly explained pay plan, and a steady flow of work. Advisors play a part too, because they turn what the tech finds into approved hours.

Why is the SERVICE ADVISOR considered the technician’s customer?

The advisor is the person who converts a tech’s findings into approved work. When a technician documents the inspection clearly with notes and video, the advisor can sell with confidence. More approved work means more flagged hours for the tech.

How should a dealership handle a check-engine light that comes back within two days or 30 miles?

Treat it as the shop’s responsibility and don’t charge another diagnosis. Manny’s quality check has the tech drive four or five miles and confirm readiness. A porter then drives about 20 miles, shuts the car off, locks it, and lets it sleep. After a second key cycle, the porter drives another 20 miles back, so the tech’s flat-rate time isn’t spent behind the wheel.

Why shouldn’t a dealership train only its service advisors?

Advisors can’t sell work the shop doesn’t have the capacity to complete. Chris Collins says that training advisors alone leads to an implosion, because the extra work lands on a short-staffed shop and the techs revolt. Adding technicians first gives advisors room to sell.

Can a service department improve profit by cutting expenses?

Controlling spending is good stewardship, but Chris says his team has never scaled a department’s profit by cutting expenses. The bigger levers are discounting and shop efficiency, including unproductive wages such as overstaffed quick-lube stalls.


Ready to Strengthen Your Fixed Ops Systems?

Achieving and exceeding your goals is possible with the right systems in place. With Service Drive Revolution OnDemand, you’ll gain access to the proven systems that have made thousands of SERVICE MANAGERS IRREPLACEABLE. Start transforming your department today!

Need help updating your playbook? Let us know how we can support your team’s growth.

Book a 15-minute strategy session with our team. We’ll explore how to unlock your dealership’s real value.


Service Drive Revolution – Episode #384 Transcript

Who Is Responsible For Techs Making Money? Service Drive Revolution #384

Hosts: Chris Collins, Hogi, Adam Krey

Guest: Manny the Mechanic

In This Episode

  • A conversation with Manny the Mechanic on flat-rate pay, technician work ethic, and personal responsibility in the shop
  • Why dealerships leaving a community costs far more than most people realize — jobs, sales tax, and opportunity
  • Inside Chris Collins Inc.’s actual coaching system: the strategy session, the interview process, boot camp, and the 30/45/90-day rollout
  • Real client results: an 11-store heavy truck group that went from mostly unprofitable to 224% net improvement, a Hyundai store that jumped from 20% to 35% net-to-gross in a month, and more
  • Why cutting expenses is almost never how profitable fixed ops departments are built — and what actually moves the needle
  • Diagnostic comebacks, check-engine lights, and how to build real trust with a full inspection instead of a single fix
  • Why the advisor — not the customer — is the technician’s real “customer,” and what that means for communication
  • Why the industry lost a generation’s passion for cars, and what it will take to get it back

Opening

Introduction and Bears vs. Packers Week

Chris Collins: Welcome, everybody, to Service Drive Revolution. I hope you are having a great day so far. Today we have a special guest, and we’re going to be talking about who’s responsible for techs making money. We got a lot of traction with our “Socialism in the Shop” topic, and so we’ve made some friends around the industry — and we have Manny the Mechanic here.

I’ll introduce him, but basically what you should do is go to his Instagram — Manny Mechanics. Same thing on TikTok. Follow him, he’s really cool. Hogi turned us on to him. Manny’s built a reputation for telling it like it is when it comes to technician productivity, work ethic, and making money in the shop. He’s an outspoken defender of flat-rate pay and isn’t afraid to call out technicians or management when they’re getting it wrong. So welcome to the show, Manny. We’re excited to hear it.

Manny the Mechanic: Thank you guys for having me. This is an honor to be here, especially on a special day like Veterans Day. Shout-out to all the veterans. Thank you for having me.

Chris: Yeah, the vets for sure. And there was no traffic — that was even better. When I got here I was like, “What holiday? What’s going on?” Manny also brought us tequila and cigars.

Hogi: Oh yeah, a man after my own heart.

Chris: You read my mind — this is one of my favorite tequilas too. I hope you enjoy it, really, really good. And then say hello to the Oklahoma Smoke Show.

Hogi: What’s up, everybody?

Chris: Adam?

Adam: Hello, everyone. It’s going to be a fun show today.

Chris: We’re going to have a good time. We owe the veterans a lot.

Hogi: Yes, we do. It’s the reason why we can do what we do.

Chris: Our military is badass. Number one in the world. Best country in the world. It’s incredible — the people that passionately serve and risk their lives for us to have what we have is something very special, and kind of beyond words, right?

Manny: Yeah. It’s good.


Manny’s Social Media Journey — and Why Dealerships Matter to a Community

Chris: So, super fun one — how are your stats on Instagram? Are you growing pretty fast?

Manny: You know, I’ve grown it — I think in the last year it’s gone up pretty quick, just doing a lot of videos and getting help. What really helped me grow my Instagram was I took a workshop — it was for contractors. This guy was running a workshop teaching people how to get on social media, how to attract customers, and how to show your work. So I ended up taking that class, not being a contractor, just being like, “Oh, well, I’m a mechanic.”

I was in a room full of contractors. I took that class because social media is something that’s growing — I think everybody should have it, especially if you’re in business or want to grow a brand. That’s how I got into it — just showing my work. I saw it take off talking about auto mechanics, and then talking about flat rate was a big one — you’d get a lot of traffic.

Also defending flat rate in some of the dealerships, because I feel like they get a bad reputation. There are a lot of guys that see the dealership as the evil empire, when if you don’t have dealerships, there’s going to be no cars. I’ve seen it in communities like where I grew up, in the city of Whittier — we’ve lost four dealerships. We’ve lost Dodge, Volvo, and they’re gone, haven’t come back.

All we have left is a Toyota and a Honda dealership. If you were to lose that, people don’t understand the income you’re losing, because every car you sell, the community gets that money — all the sales tax. I’ve interviewed the mayor, I try to get involved in city council, try to help better our community for my kids, because they don’t want to leave the city we grew up in. Seeing the impact of dealerships leaving for other areas — it’s devastating.

You lose jobs, a lot of jobs. People don’t understand how many people a dealership employs. They work in the community, and they’re good jobs too — good jobs for somebody like me. I didn’t go to college. To be able to make the sort of living I make in automotive, it’s kind of special.

Chris: It’s an industry based on the premise that if you work hard and get results, you can participate in the upside.

Manny: Yeah. I’ve seen it firsthand. I didn’t have any goals to go to college — for me, I was done with school, so I went to UTI, and I just fell in love with it. Once I started there and saw the electrical class, it really opened my eyes. Doing electrical, trying to figure out a short — “Hey, I have a short to ground, I’m checking continuity” — to me, that blew my mind. How much goes into a car, how much a computer does just to keep you on the road idling. Now you step on it, you’ve got a throttle signal, this and that. To me, that was awesome. That’s what hooked me — the electronics of the vehicle.

Chris: That’s great. And you’re a Raiders fan, and I’m a Raiders fan.

Hogi: You know who I’m a fan of, right? The Seahawks.

Chris: This week, we’ll see.

Hogi: Yeah, we’ll see. I feel bad for your quarterback.

Manny: I would’ve let Cousins stay one more week if you could.

Chris: Well, they had the trade deadline, so they had to do it.

Manny: Do you know how many quarterbacks we’ve ruined?

Chris: Don’t say that.

Manny: A lot. That’s the worst first start for that kid, I think.

Chris: Hopefully it’s at home.

Manny: Yeah, in Vegas. I hope you guys have a good line. I like the Raiders too — your coach is our old offensive coordinator, and I think he’s done a pretty good job.

Chris: Yeah, I think he’s turning it around.

Manny: I do too. I think they’ve got a bright future.

Chris: They play better.


Growing the Show — and Why the Best and Worst Techs Are the Ones Who Leave

Chris: So our thing — we’ve almost doubled our subscribers just this year. I think there’s more and more people out there looking for a conversation and a community to talk about stuff. For Service Drive Revolution, this is our best year — the amount of subscribers and views we get. When we look out there, we’re the number one show for automotive, internally speaking. There’s a lot of people teaching consumer stuff — how not to get ripped off, car reviews — but for a show that’s just for the industry, we get way more downloads than Automotive News or anything like that. It’s crazy. I think it’s just because we’re human, we’re normal people. I’ve been surprised by how much the channel has grown, and I hope you see the same sort of thing with what you’re doing.

Manny: I hope it grows. Yeah, it’s growing slowly. I’m hoping to grow organically and just have people who really want to listen to the message. Having my own little podcast has helped — interviewing guys who’ve left the dealership, asking why they left and getting their input. I think the majority of the guys leaving the dealership are either the best techs, or some of the worst ones who aren’t getting things done. The middle guys kind of stay — what I like to call the cruisers, the guys who get there seven or eight hours a day. I think those guys are staying. But the top-tier guys are saying, “Why am I going to stay here when I can open my own shop and do my own thing?”

A lot of people have told me, “Why don’t you just open up your own shop?” It’s funny — when I complain to my dad, I tell him, “I’m human, I have complaints too, I just don’t let people know, because there’s enough of that going on on social media.” I tell it to my dad, and my dad always says, “Well, who’s to blame?” I’m like, “Who?” He’s like, “You. You go to work there every day. Why don’t you open up your own shop and do whatever you want?” If you decide to clock in and be on their dime, then you’ve got to take responsibility. It’s good advice from my dad. I have no one to blame but myself.

Chris: That’s what I love about what you do. One, you have a great personality and common sense, but also you’re trying to see both sides. America’s built on personal responsibility. You’ve got to own your own thing, and I think we’re getting away from that in a lot of ways.

Manny: Yeah, it’s good.


How We Actually Get Our Results

Chris: Before we get to who’s responsible for techs making money, I wanted to talk a little bit about how we get the results we get in service departments. Our social media always wants to put our stats up, but what I’ve learned over time is our stats scare people away, because they think, “That’s not possible, it’s made up.” It becomes an objection where we just get discounted right away — “There’s no way you did that that quickly.”

I want to go over some of the stats, but then I want to talk about the system we’re currently using. I can’t point out enough how we are always trying to get our clients to grow, improve, and get better — and we’re always doing the same thing on our end. The system we were running last year is completely different from the system we’re running this year. We’re always trying to figure out how to get a better outcome for our clients, how to make their customer experience better, and how to make them more profitable.

I’m going to go through the system we’re running right now — jump in if I miss any parts of this — but I just want to explain that the results we get are not by accident. It’s manufactured, it’s very thought out, it’s tested, something we’re always working on and paying attention to — how can we make it better?

Recent Results

We’ll start with some recent stats. We have a heavy truck dealership in the Midwest with 11 locations, and their net, in a very short period of time, more than doubled — up 224%. The biggest deal is that for the first time ever, all 11 departments were profitable.

Hogi: For the first time that year.

Chris: Yeah. Insane. Some of those stores were profitable just off the training in the boot camp, because we were doing more of a hub-and-spoke model — working with one main store as the example, with the others following along.

Then I have a Hyundai store — I’m going to guess this is in the Northeast. They went from 20% net-to-gross to 35% net-to-gross in just a month. A pretty dramatic change. If you’re just working in fixed ops and you’re not an owner or general manager, you need to understand that in the market we live in today, if fixed ops can put cash to the bottom line, that basically saves the business.

Dealerships are losing a lot of money on the front end. Used cars aren’t carrying it in most situations, and inventories are rising. Dealerships run out of cash, and the owners or investors have to recapitalize. There’s a lot of dealerships right now having to recapitalize — put a couple million dollars back into the business just to get it to float. When fixed ops is making $150,000 a month in cash, that basically saves the business. High fixed absorption right now is a big deal. The Hyundai store went from 20% to 35%, and they hired two techs very quickly.

The next one is a Ford dealership in the Midwest. It was negative 65% net-to-gross, a six-month average. Over the next six months, they were positive 43.65% net-to-gross, which is insane. We added basically six technicians there — it’s a pretty big store too. We’ve literally run into stores where the general idea is, “If service could just not lose $50,000, we’re happy,” which is insane.

Fixed absorption is getting to be a sexy metric again. There’s nothing wrong with tracking that number, but when you start looking at some of these stores and the net-profit addition from just little adjustments, that’s the crazy thing. We’re super intentional about our system. When you implement that with the repair orders you already have, add a couple techs, and become a little more intentional, these dollars are already laying on your ROs. When you start talking about going from 15% net-to-gross to 30% net-to-gross and doubling your net profit, it’s very achievable. It makes your cash position for the store completely different.

This is a Subaru store in the Midwest. It had a pretty high RO count, but the RO count was basically even. In September they were negative 30% net-to-gross. In October, positive 2%. That’s a 32% swing. The first step when you’re losing money in a department is to break even, and then profitability — this is normal, you go from losing a pretty good clip to breaking even, and it climbs from there. They went from an ELR of $156 to an ELR of $166. A lot of that is just in the work mix — they went from 1.35 hours per RO to 1.59, and then sold more stuff along the way. Those little incremental changes are really their first month on the program.

Here’s a Kia store — it was at 20% net-to-gross and went to 41% net-to-gross. Hours per RO went up pretty well. ELR went up $10 — not huge, but a meaningful change. Here’s another Ford one: negative 51%, then positive 4% — that’s a 55% swing, basically. The biggest change is the techs. You’re not going to make these kinds of turnarounds without adding capacity. We get calls saying, “We need advisor training.”

A hundred percent of the time, if we come in and just train your advisors, you’re going to implode. You have to have the capacity in the shop to do the work. The techs are everything. If you don’t have the ability to do the work, advisor training isn’t the answer. Most of the time, advisors can’t sell the work because they’re afraid of doing it and damaging their CSI. We hold advisors accountable for CSI and then tell them to sell more — but if they can’t get the work done, they’re not going to do that. The techs will have an uprising.

The System, Step by Step

The process of how we do it now — and I think a big part of our success starts with the strategy session — is this: when somebody approaches us and says, “I need help in my service department or departments,” we get the numbers and do a projection. We do a deep dive into the financials, and then we do a strategy session. I’m pretty good at determining whether they’re a fit or not. I feel really bad taking a chance on somebody I know is either not ethical or just not a good leader. If you don’t know that you want to get better and what that looks like, we’re not a match. Our coaches are designed to be vested in the outcome — in the customer experience and the profitability — not just to train, get everybody fired up, and leave.

The customer experience has to get better, and we should be making more profit in that scenario. We don’t take everybody, and we’re not a match for everybody. Our coaches are leaving home, staying in hotels, showing up with the expectation of making a difference. If you show up somewhere and they aren’t doing what they say they’re going to do, they aren’t ready, or they’ve got the factory rep there saying the same thing — the incompatibility is clear. A huge portion of the coach’s pay is based on the results of that store. If it’s more important to the coach to get results out of the store than it is to the client, then it’s not a match.

Once we decide it’s a match and something we want to do together, the first step is that we come out and interview everybody in service and parts. We ask them a series of questions because we want to get to know the business. We watch your processes and do a deep dive on pay plans, pricing strategies, the customer experience, receivables, and everything else that helps us understand the department, the market, and the people. Part of our system is that people will often pay us just to do that, because the feedback you get from it is incredible. Most of the time, you have no idea what’s really going on in your department.

Manny, how many times in your dealership career has somebody sat down with you for an hour and said, “Manny, how do you think we could make it better?”

Manny: In my 26-year career, we just had that happen maybe three or four months ago. Our auto group started a technician meeting, and techs from every department got together. We went in there, said things, and they asked us questions. I think that was the first step in the auto group realizing they needed to change something, because techs are leaving. Without techs, you can’t really do anything. In my 26-year career, nobody ever cared. They were just like, “Hey, keep wrenching.”

Chris: You’re blown away in that process by how smart your people really are. They’re on the front lines, and nobody’s asking them how to go to war every day. We’re also a fresh set of eyes — we’re in hundreds of dealerships and have been doing this a long time. We bring expertise and perspective that you don’t see when you’re putting your head down and working every day, we have a piece of art here that’s a jar, and it says, “You can’t read the label of the jar you’re in.” We have a different perspective because we’re not attached to it, see what’s working and what isn’t. Our ability to see your full potential is usually very different from what you see as your full potential. Your full potential is usually much bigger than you think.

From all that feedback and research, we go away and put together a plan. Depending on the timing, you come out here to LA for a day and a half and go through a boot camp. The real leverage is getting out of your business, being uninterrupted, and focusing on the plan and fixed ops. More is taught and discovered in that meeting than probably anything else. We’ve had people doing this for 30 years — managers for 30 years — who don’t really understand how to make a service department work.

Then we present your plan. We go through it, agree on what we want to do, and build a timeline. The plan always includes hiring techs, possibly moving a desk, and whatever else is necessary. We might say, “We think we can have this done in 30 or 45 days.” In some situations we have to hire 15 techs, and that takes about 45 days. The most techs we’ve ever hired is around 30 in 45 days. It’s hard to hire techs, and you can’t shortcut it. If you paid an agency to come out and hire techs, they might charge $10,000 to $15,000 per person, and it would take them much longer.

Once we have everything in place, we kick off the changes and follow them. You could put a marker on the calendar six months out, and everybody will revert back to the old way — the 90-day bell curve — unless you anticipate it and get ahead of it. The first year in our program, you start to understand what’s possible and start having fun. Clients get the best results in the second year, because they have a new language and a new way of thinking.

Taking employee feedback and making it part of the plan gets a lot of buy-in and creates momentum. Having a fresh set of eyes on your business helps too. Our expectation is that we double your sales and more than double your net profit — but perhaps more importantly, we create a better culture, better morale, and more fun. That’s probably just as rewarding as anything else. We had our call with our team last night going through the results and what’s going on — it’s very fun and inspiring.

Hogi: The only thing I would add is that it’s great for the team and morale. Seeing it on paper is a big shot in the arm. You believe that you can do it, and then it starts growing. All those stores are going to have record months for the next several months.

Chris: What I enjoy more than anything is watching the customer’s face when we’re first starting out, and then watching their face 90 days into it. That is really rewarding.


Viewer Questions

Chris: I know we had questions in the thing, but my screen disappeared.

Hogi: Yeah, the crawler pig is on fire. He shot out of a cannon this morning.

Chris: Would you ever have the name Roller Pig as your name?

Manny: No, I don’t think I would. I think Manny Mechanics is pretty good.

Chris: I love bacon too much. I actually named a dog Bacon.

Hogi: He says: “What’s your top three expenses that you see are higher than they should be when you inspect dealer financials?”

Chris: Uniforms for employees who were fired six months ago. Brake-clean cans versus buying in bulk — so we’re talking shop supplies.

Hogi: Doesn’t it sound like Roller Pig is making a statement, not a question?

Chris: It’s more of a statement. Make sure your guys get taken off the uniform bill — check your policy.

Where Profitability Actually Comes From

When you’re talking about profitability, if your first reaction is to run to expenses — out of all those results, one thing that’s overwhelmingly true, out of the hundreds and hundreds of stores we’ve helped scale their profitability, is that never once have we done it by going in and cutting expenses. Be a good steward of your department, pay attention to what you’re spending, make sure the uniform company isn’t adding five rugs to the bill and spreading them across the building every time they come in.

But you’re not going to cut your way into a highly scalable profit. The two things I think of probably aren’t expenses in the sense of how you see them: discounting is usually out of control, and the other is shop efficiency and gross-profit percentage. In a lot of stores, you’re running two quick-lube techs to a stall and paying those quick-lube techs $25 an hour — your cost of labor is $50 an hour. There’s no way you’re making a profit at that. The math isn’t working. Focus on inefficiency and unproductive wages.

Diagnostic Comebacks and Check-Engine Lights

Hogi: He says: “A diagnosed and fixed XYZ warning — if the client comes back two days or 30 miles later and the light is back on, what’s your time and distance for a quality check?” What do you think, Manny?

Manny: When it comes to check-engine lights, it’s hard — you have a lot of systems in there. What I like to do is maybe a four- or five-mile test drive, possibly getting it through readiness to make sure. As a smog technician, I think that’s one of the tools you have — if you get it through readiness, that should be good enough. But we don’t want the tech spending time driving a car, so I’d give it to a porter.

Maybe the tech drives it four miles before and four miles after, then hands it over to a porter who drives it 20 miles, turns it off, locks the car, lets it go to sleep, does another key cycle, turns it back on, and drives back another 20 miles. If the 40-mile check with two key cycles works, I think you’re solid. It’s hard to hit all those different drive cycles nowadays.

Chris: But wouldn’t you say that if it’s two days or 30 miles later, it’s on us?

Manny: I would say yes. You’re responsible for the car. If you want to keep customers happy, you have to understand that when the check-engine light comes back on, they don’t know why — they just know the light is back on and they paid you to fix it. That’s why we’re the experts. I’m certainly not charging them for diagnosis there. If it’s a different part, I might say, “You needed this part, and now you need this part” — sometimes they work in a series, you need to figure out exactly what it is. But I’m not charging a diagnosis to figure that out. You also have to inform the customer and talk to your advisor and give them a lot of information.

One of the things I started doing is implementing AI, learning from a class. You can go to ChatGPT and say, “I have these three codes, can you explain them to me?” I might tell it, “This one’s an O2 sensor, there’s an oil trap, this is catalyst efficiency — can you give me a description of all three?” Then I ask it to make a template for the advisor and explain how we started with the first repair, while making the customer aware that the other codes might come back. It’s like Veterans Day — one shot, one kill. You take the time to make the one shot and really inform your customer the first time.

The Case for a Thorough Inspection

Manny: You also need to take the time to do a thorough inspection. I’ve seen guys recommend catalytic converters, which are very expensive, but they have to do it — especially here in California to get the tags right. Then they recommend $8,000 in catalytic converters but don’t check something like the cooling system. Maybe there are hoses starting to leak — they didn’t check the radiator because they were focused on the check-engine light and failed smog check.

They overlook the rest of the car, don’t check the brakes or other systems. Doing a thorough inspection protects the dealership. You can say, “I know this is a check-engine light and a failed emissions test, but I want to make sure the cooling system is okay. I’m going to pull the dipstick and make sure the oil is clean.” I’m not just going to say, “Catalyst-efficiency code, I’m going to recommend two catalytic converters and O2 sensors,” and then send it on its way. At the dealership level, that’s not providing value, in my opinion. When your labor rate is high, you’ve got to provide value to your customer.

Chris: Yeah, complete inspections. You covered Roller Pig’s other question too: how do you tell a flat-rate tech to drive the car 50 miles and start and stop 20 times to ensure the diagnosis?

Manny: I think it’s important to tell the client, “You had three codes. We think this one thing — your O2 sensor, for example — is going to fix it. But if it comes back on, we might need to do something else.” It’s like with hoses: “These hoses were all born together, they grew up together, they find the path of least resistance. If we replace one, there’s a good chance another one is going to leak.” Oftentimes you sell all the hoses at one time — as an advisor, you replace one hose and then instantly the pressure causes another one to fail.

Chris: I like how you framed that, Manny, because part of why I got into this industry is that my mom was tired of going to dealerships by herself and not really knowing much. You’re explaining the systems — not going into every technical detail, but breaking them down and setting expectations. You explain that this could be the cause of the symptoms, but solving it holistically isn’t always a one-and-done thing.

Something similar happened to me recently. My wife’s vehicle was getting tired, and we needed to put tires on it. We already had one failed TPMS sensor that I had replaced because its battery was going out. I said, “We’re getting the tires, so just do the other three — I’m not dealing with it anymore.” That’s like doing a full inspection — checking everything and getting it done at once. A lot of people are on the move and can only get things done at one time. They don’t want to keep scheduling repairs.

The Advisor Is the Tech’s Real Customer

Manny: Either you’re educating the advisor, or you’re setting them up. I think that’s where a lot of techs fail — they see the advisor as, “If I inform them, do a video inspection, and do this, I’m basically doing their job and making it easy for them.” As a tech, a lot of guys don’t realize that the advisor is your customer. The customer — the owner of the car — is not your customer. The advisor is. If you keep your advisor happy and inform them, they can do their job.

I’ve trained advisors before — I’d coach them on selling and how to present things to customers. One of them was brand new to the industry, and I told her, “Our customers are very smart. The people at the car dealership or manufacturer are very smart — these are lawyers and doctors, and they read body language. If you’re talking to them and there’s a little bit of uncertainty, they’re going to know you’re unsure. You have to be direct.

If you don’t know, say, ‘Mr. Customer, I don’t know if this is going to fix it, but my tech said X, Y, and Z, and we need to follow this.’ If you don’t think you want to spend the money on this car, then let’s not fix it and get you over to sales.” There’s a responsibility there too. If you have a 2012 car with a dead cylinder and you’re going to recommend an engine or a teardown, you have to consider the value. You might say, “Mr. Customer, maybe it’s time to think about a new car and trade this one in.” When you do that much work, other things will start going wrong too.

Chris: Exactly. It’s going to have a bunch of cousins wanting more money.

Hogi: We dealt with that a lot in commercial trucks — with many 10- or 12-year-old pieces of equipment, the residual value is low, and it’s often better to get a new one. What would you say, Manny?

Manny: We have an interesting experience in that we work in heavy-truck dealerships where the majority of the dealerships are hourly — the techs are hourly, not flat rate. We run into situations where we put bonus programs in to incentivize them to be more productive, and they don’t even understand that they can flag more than 100%. It’s not their fault — it’s our fault as leaders, but it’s such a strange thing. On the car-dealership side, it’s a completely different world where it’s flat rate.

The majority of dealerships are flat rate, and your best technicians make a good living based on performance. The cultures in the two different shops are so different. When we were talking about “Socialism in the Shop,” there’s a ton of younger techs talking about how unfair it is and wanting a guarantee, without understanding that they can create their own rate and their own income. What would you say to the younger kids coming up who feel like they should be entitled to something instead of earning flat rate?


Advice for Young Techs: “You Control Your Own Destiny”

Manny: I would say to the young tech that this is a great industry because you basically control your own destiny. You go into a shop and, as long as the work is there, you can make as much as you’re willing to make through flat rate. My goal has always been to make 20 hours a day — “today I’m going to go in, kill it, and make 20 hours.” That’s my goal. Some days I hit more, some days I hit less. A lot of guys feel like everything should be handed to them, but they don’t have the skills or tools. I’ve seen that in our own shop — guys say, “I want to flag what you’re flagging.” Be careful what you wish for, because you’re taking a 20-minute lunch and you’re always on the go.

It starts with your stall. Don’t worry about anything else — block out the whole world and worry about your stall and the car in front of you. You’ve got to do the little things. Keep your stall clean and know where your tools are. My setup is everything in one cart — I don’t go into my toolbox at all. Everything is there, all the sockets, all the tools, everything. Every step you take, you’re losing money, and you’ve got to have that perspective.

A lot of techs want everything to be easy, but it doesn’t work that way. This is an industry where you have to put in the time and go home and keep learning. When I’m helping my kids with homework, I bring out wiring diagrams or work on a timing belt for a brand-new car — I’m reading about it. My kids say, “You have homework too?” Yeah. We’re all professionals. We’re all doing homework together. Homework never ends. Never stop learning.

Chris: Exactly. A master tech in 2025 will not be a master tech in 2026, and a master tech in 2026 will not be a master tech in 2027, because cars change. The human body hasn’t changed, but cars change every day — every year you get a new model. A lot of guys don’t want to put in that time. They feel like the dealership is charging $300 an hour and they’re only making a third or an eighth of that, so it isn’t fair.

Manny: I don’t think the passion is there. I blame the industry itself, because we got rid of wood shop, metal shop, and automotive shop in high schools. Southern California used to be a hub for automotive racing — Carroll Shelby came out of here. We had a bunch of racetracks, and that’s all gone away. But the automotive industry is not dead. You saw SEMA — it was fully packed. You also see the takeovers happening in LA, with kids peeling out and doing burnouts. It’s illegal, and they shouldn’t be doing it, but they don’t have anywhere to go, and nobody has invested in the youth to show them what they can do with that passion.

I’d say they have to look at it and ask whether they really want to get into the industry and give it time. It’s going to take five or ten years to hone your automotive skills. You’re not going to learn it in one day or one week. It takes a lot of time, and you have to keep up. Even I struggle with cars from 2010. If you give me a Volvo 240, I’m looking at it thinking, “How do I work on this? It has a cap and rotor — I haven’t seen this in years.”

If you’re one of those young guys who doesn’t want to learn every day, this probably isn’t the industry for you. It’s not going to be handed to you. You just read the numbers of the dealerships that were struggling — you helped bring those numbers up. That’s what they’re looking at every month, and you have to be part of that wheel and try to make an impact as a tech. You’ve got to be willing to carry your own weight.

Chris: You bring up an interesting thing — the workforce. It’s crazy that kids go to college, come out with $200,000 in student loans, and there are no jobs for them. You could go to vocational school and become a tech, make an incredible living, and avoid those student loans. We’ve failed as a country in that way, because our workforce doesn’t match the demand. It starts when they’re young — you’ve got to get them excited about cars when they’re young. The passion is there when you’re young.

Manny: I started when I was 12. I had an uncle who worked for GM. After school, my dad would drop me off at my uncle’s house. My uncle had to retire because of a medical condition, but he never stopped working in his garage. I remember going there for the first time — we were taking an engine out in his backyard, on the grass, and I fell in love with it.


About Service Drive Revolution Academy

I know from experience that a lot of dealer owners won’t invest in training for fixed ops — but eight SERVICE MANAGERS in our coaching group have been promoted to general managers. That doesn’t happen enough in our industry. It’s proof that when you’re given the right tools and the right mentorship, you can do amazing things.

I’d like to personally invite you to something that should exist already, but unfortunately doesn’t: a live Fixed Ops Academy — a mentorship, a community. It’s a Service Drive Revolution Academy. Anybody can afford it; anybody who wants to invest in themselves can join. We teach what we know about running a healthy fixed-ops service business. Our average coaching client performs well above the industry average, and a handful are in a league completely their own — if I told you their numbers, you wouldn’t believe it.


Feel free to explore the linked articles above for deeper insights into each strategy. If you have any further questions or need additional resources, don’t hesitate to ask!

Recommended Posts

AUTOMOTIVE CONSULTANTS AT WORK

Automotive consultants are employed by dealerships and other car companies to help in developing their businesses and, in turn, increase profits. They also might work

Contact Us

Name(Required)
Text Message Opt In
Chris Collins Inc. logo featuring stylized text and illustrated face design.

Get weekly Fixed Ops strategies, leadership insights, and service drive tactics from Chris Collins & the SDR coaching team — delivered straight to your inbox.

LIMITED TIME EVENT

Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
Join me as I tell the stories from my best-selling book.

1: Contact Information

2. Payment Information

Millionaire Service Advisor and Irreplaceable Service Manager books by Chris Collins

Claim Yours Before We
Run Out Of Stock!

$74.95 $39.95

This Step By Step Guide Will Teach You How To…

  • Create a workplace you and your employees love!
  • Drive traffic and increase your RO count!
  • Significantly increase your CSI count!
  • Create lifetime customer loyalty!
  • And so much more!
 

Get Free Access to Our M.O.R.E Technician Recruiting Workbook!

First enter your best email address below so we know where to send it!
 
Automotive leadership and service manager training banner promoting Chris Collins Inc. programs for car dealership growth and performance.
Man writing profit and cost calculations on a transparent board
 

We respect your privacy. Your email will never be shared